Tiffany’s Sweets, Eats And Meeting Place

Reviews

• Cara C.

  star star star star star 18 September 2026

  I have had coworkers bring in stuff from here but I had never been to this place of happiness.
  The serve food and it is great but who cares because we are really here for the deserts right?
  It was so hard to choose just one so we all picked one and shared. I don't even know what the other two deserts were but I was magically transported to a happy unicorn filled world where there was no pain when I took a bite. My Apple Danish was good but I had played it safe. Next time I am getting adventurous and will try everything!!!

• Nicole M.

  star star star star star 17 September 2026

  This may be my new stomping grounds in Columbia. Forget this place just being a bakery. While their glass display still boasts the bright and shiny sugar confections their lunch menus are just as noteworthy.
  
  I had a beautiful, low carb citrus chicken salad! My mom had a big bowl of blackened shrimp jumbo! Both were amazing. Do not write this place off as just a sweet spot. Come check it out.
  
  Booth seating, a bar, beautiful decor, a nod to their old building with the Tiffany chandeliers, and amazing confectionary treats. What's not to love!!!
  
  Don't take my word for it. Come for a visit and be amazing at the new location and all the good stuff they have to offer. I highly recommend this place for catching up with friends and family get togethers.

• Ron V.

  star star star star star 13 September 2026

  Went to the new location for lunch with about eight of our lunch group.   We took a table over to the left side which held us all.  We each placed our order at the counter and they brought each meal out separately.  Didn't take too long and actually they all come out about two at a time and close to each other, so there wasn't much waiting for everyone to get their food.
  
  Great menu, with a lot of selections from burgers, sandwiches, wraps, salads, etc.  I ordered a Patty Melt on marble rye.  Comes with house fries or fruit.  I selected the house fries.  The Patty melt was excellent. I ordered it medium well, built it was really medium, but no problem, still great.  Fries were good.  My friend said the Mediterranean Greek Salad was very good.  Most of their salads are served in a large deep fried tortilla bowl.  They look great.  One person ordered the chicken salad as a sandwich (on bread) rather than getting it in the tortilla bowl.  Another ordered the Drunken Burger, and let me tell you, it was a huge burger.  I don't know what was in it but it was piled about 4-5 inches high.  Another ordered the black and blue burger and said it was good.
  
  It got pretty crowded by 12:00 and the new location seems to be a hit.  I'll be taking the wife back this weekend for her to try.
  
  Update:  My wife and I have gone back two Saturdays in a row for lunch.  Our first visit was great.  She had the Patty Melt on Marble Rye and loved it.  I tried the Cuban sandwich, which was also great.  Probably one of the best I've had.  The pickle that they serve with their sandwiches is the best pickle I've ever had.  My wife agreed.  They are homemade and I told the waitstaff they should sell them.  He said they were going to start selling them in the future, as they've had a number of requests for them.
  
  Second Saturday, 5/17 visit; My wife had the Greek Chicken Salad in the tortilla shell.  It was great. Chicken was good, grilled, and the salad dressing was very good.  I decided to try the French Dip with horseradish dip also.  I must say, it was the saltiest au jus I have ever tasted.  I like salt, but this was over the top.  One of the chefs, or possibly owners, came by and asked us how the food was.  I told him the food has been excellent except for the au jus.  Way too salty.  He agreed with me and said they buy that in and don't make it there.  I don't think I'll order that again at all.  My wife was a tad upset that they actually charged her $.25 for a glass of water.  She said "I don't mean to be a tight was, but it's the principle of charging for water."  MacDonalds or other fast food establishments don't charge for water.  The other issue with Tiffany's, and hopefully it's because they are still trying to get their act together after just opening for a couple of weeks, is the long single line of waiting to place your order with the one cashier that takes your order and rings it up.  Tiffany's is a bakery, but they've expanded to be be a bakery, restaurant and bar.  Yet, they are treating it as a bakery where you wait in line to order.  I know they are trying to hire more employees, but right now it's a real pain, especially over lunch hour, to wait in line to place an order.  The food is excellent...just hope they get their workforce in place before too long.
  
  We did see their "Shared Menu" for evenings and that looks very good as well.  They serve small appetizer plates with a good selection of beer and wine and have a nice charcuterie board available also.

• Ellen W.

  star star star star star 11 September 2026

  The new location is just lovely. They didn't skimp on the decor.
  
  I had a French dip sandwich for lunch and it was so tender and juicy. It came with fruit and a pickle. The drink machine has Cheerwine on tap, something I've rarely seen.
  
  I bought a dozen wedding cookies on my way out. Boy, are they good!

• Lauren C.

  star star star star_border star_border 9 September 2026

  The new location is very convenient and the building is attractive. However, I'm a little confused about the set up. I don't really understand the reasoning behind the separate "community room" that serves alcohol, that the restaurant portion closes at certain times of the day, and the counter service. Not to mention that the desserts are WAY OVERPRICED for the quality. The fried green tomatoes were really good, but I was hoping for more, especially with the baked goods.